REFEREE RATINGS FOR 2004-2005
A quick listing of the referees Saints have in their
competitive games this season along with an average rating out of 10 and
description of the various cock-ups they made. Suggestions for suitable
awards to the best/ worst of the season and any additional ratings to
refvote@grange.demon.co.uk.
Last Seasons Inagural Votes are available for perusal
for 1997-98, 1998-99,
1999-2000, 2000-01,
2001-02, 2002-03
and 2002-03
Current
Ratings ::
Match Details +
Total Ratings
Kevin Toner
(Gourock) - Back to Ref League Table
- 26/12/04 - Saints v Raith 39 (6
votes) - Decent enough game but strangely only yellow-carded the
Raith defender for a last-man challenge. Still let play flow and didn't
create too much controversy.
- 07/05/05 - Saints v St Midden 43 (10
votes) - OK game with no cards shown and an attempt to let play
flow.
Calum Murray-
Back to Ref League Table
- 31/08/04 Saints v QoS (Bells Cup) - 29
(5 votes)- Seen a lot worse but some strange decisions and some
needless bookings. Still tried to let the game flow and picked up on the
niggly challenges
- 03/01/05 - Ross Co v Saints 28 (6
votes) - A poor game with some strange decisions. Little in the
way of real controversy though.
- 30/04/05 - QoS v Saints 17 (6 votes)
- Tried to let the game flow but some strange decisions. Should
have booked Bayne for diving.
Crawford AllanBack
to Ref League Table
- 23/04/05 - Saints v Airdrie 30 (8
votes) - So-so game with some dodgy decisions but nothing really
controversial.
Charlie
Richmond- Back to Ref League Table
- 21/08/04 St Mirren v Saints37 (21
votes)- Jesus where to start. Red-carded three Saints players as
well as letting St Midden away with plenty of dirty challenges. Dire.
Far too happy with the cards when a simple warning would have sufficed
early on.
- 11/12/04 Airdrie v Saints 21 (8
votes) - No cards flashed but not much else to recommend another
poor whistle-happy performance.
- 16/04/05 Partick v Saints 19 (4
votes) - Crap again - too many soft bookings, and whistle-happy
decisions.
Craig Mackay
- Back to Ref League Table
- 04/09/04 Accies v Saints - 38 (7
votes)- Pretty poor performance with too many soft decisions but
at least he was crap for both teams.
- 30/10/04 - Raith v Saints - 27 (5
votes) - Some contentious moments but little in the way of real
controversy although he could have punished some of the timewasting and
faked injuries.
- 09/04/05 Saints v Clyde 31 (6 votes)
- An ok game but some soft cards dished out.
Stuart Dougal
(Burnside) - Back to Ref League Table
- 02/10/04 Clyde v Saints 25 (6 votes)-
Christ but he's dire - when will we get some sort of consistency in a
game that this idiot referees. An embarassment.
- 12/03/05 Raith v Saints 25 (4 votes)
- Not a disaster but some soft fouls carded and harsher ones allowed to
go. Still he's been a lot worse.
Kenny Clark
(Paisley) - Back to Ref League Table
- 18/09/04 Saints v Falkirk 34 (14
votes)- Nightmare game. Red-carded Maxwell towards the end but
was far too willing to dish out cards and hold up play never mind ignore
either assistant.
- 02/04/05 Falkirk v Saints 15 (3
votes) - Average game but missed some dodgy fouls.
Dougie McDonald
(Edinburgh)- Back to Ref League Table
- 31/07/04 Saints v Accies (Bells Cup)43
(8 votes)- Oh dear - despite giving us a penalty had a very
inconsistent game with Moore kicked all over the park.
- 14/09/04 Berwick v Saints (Bell's Cup) 12
(2 votes) - Little in the way of controversy but didn't seem to
like his linesmen much!
- 09/01/05 ICT v Saints (Scottish Cup) 9
(4 votes) - Wasn't at the game so no comment / vote from me -
doesn't seem to have had that good a game though!.
- 22/03/05 Clyde v Saints 24 (4 votes)
- Decent enough game with the cards kept in pocket for the most part.
Alan Freeland
(Sheepville) - Back to Ref League Table
- 22/01/05 Saints v Partick 31(7
votes) - Far too whistle-happy and some baffling decisions. To
his credit there were no cards produced though.
- 19/03/05 Saints v Ross Co 51 (9
votes)- A bit whistle-happy again but little in the way of real
controversy.
Craig ThomsonBack
to Ref League Table
- 10/08/04 Saints v Alloa (CIS Cup)80
(13 votes)- Reasonable game given both the conditions and how
shite we were - at least he punished the timewasting towards the end.
- 28/08/04 Saints v Raith 38 (6 votes)-
Another reasonable game with the cards kept in the pocket. Some dodgy
offsides but not much to complain about.
- 16/10/04 QoS v Saints 17 (3 votes)
- Some well dodgy offsides but tried to let the game flow a bit more and
kept the cards in the pocket until late on.
- 05/03/05 Saints v Accies 52 (11
votes) - Not a bad game and deservedly red-carded Webb for the
penalty.
Hugh Dallas
(Motherwell) - Back to Ref League Table
- 07/08/04 Airdrie v Saints 22 (8
votes)- Crap, shite and very, very poor. Bit like the team then.
- 20/11/04 Falkirk v Saints 30 (9
votes)- Total idiot - far too whistle happy. Sent off Ruti as
well
- 12/02/05 St Midden v Saints38 (7
votes) - Kept the cards in his pockets for a while but in the end
booked 2 Saints and red-carded Peaso for a late challenge. To his credit
he at least tried to play the game and keep the peace.
Mike McCurry
(Wegieland) - Back to Ref League Table
- 28/09/04 Saints v Falkirk (Bells Cup) 34
(9 votes)- Nothing too bad but some strange offsides and
handballs awarded
- 18/12/04 Saints v St. Midden 48 (13
votes) - Fairly poor game but at least he tried to keep his cards
in his pockets.
- 12/02/05 Saints v QoS 36 (8 votes)
- Dire. Dodgy offsides, some strange bookings / warnings and rarely
consulted his assistants. Only consolation was the lack of red cards.
John Underhill
(Edinburgh) - Back to Ref League Table
- 06/11/04 Saints v Accies 51 (10
votes)- Far too whistle-happy but at least tried to keep the
cards in his pocket. Not helped by some very close offside decisions
though.
- 15/01/05 Saints v Falkirk 29 (8
votes) - Not a bad game but some strange decisions and seemingly
content to put up with diving and dissent all over the park.
Brian Cassidy-
Back to Ref League Table
- 29/12/04 - Hamilton v Saints 19 (5
votes) - Far too whistle-happy but to his credit he kept the
cards in his pocket for most of the game
John Rowbotham
(Kirkcaldy) - Back to Ref League Table
- 04/12/04 Partick v Saints 66 (10
votes) - Decent game and kept control of things although it
rarely threatened to boil over.
Willie Young
(Clarkston) - Back to Ref League Table
- 25/09/04 Saints v Partick 60 (8
votes)- Booked Milne eventually and had a reasonable game - still
one of the few refs who smiles to diffuse a situation.
- 27/11/04 Saints v Clyde 91 (12
votes)- Good all-round game with only 3 bookings and a
willingness to let the game flow.
Iain Brines -
Back to Ref League Table
- 13/11/04 Saints v Ross County 26 (6
votes)- Over-petty officious idiot (for both sides) with little
to endear him to Saints fans although at least he spotted the deliberate
handball leading to a County "goal".
Mike RitchieBack
to Ref League Table
- 23/10/04 Saints v Airdrie 24 (6
votes)- Saints pretty poor but referee was just as bad with some
strange fouls allowed to go unpunished but cards dished out for nothing.
Andrew Hunter
- Back to Ref League Table
- 11/09/04 Ross Co v Saints - 28 (6
votes)- Gave us a penalty and correctly red-carded McSwegan. Bit
whistle-happy at times and can't tell when 90 minutes are up but we've
had a lot lot worse.
Scott
MacDonald - Back to Ref League Table
Steven Duff-
Back to Ref League Table
- 14/08/04 Saints v QoS81
(13 votes)- Can't interpret the offside rule and far too
whistle-happy but not helped much by a crappy linesman either. And he's
fat!
Steve ConroyBack
to Ref League Table
Garry Mitchell
(Arbroath)Back to Ref League Table
John Gilmour-
Back to Ref League Table
Tom Brown
(Edinburgh) - Back to Ref League Table
Colin Hardie-
Back to Ref League Table
Craig Mackay-
Back to Ref League Table
Ian
Frickelton- Back to Ref League Table
Ian Fyfe
(Linlithgow) - Back to Ref League Table
Eddie Mack (Newton
Mearns)Back to Ref League Table
Bobby Orr
(Kilbarchan) - Back to Ref League Table
David Somers
(Cumbernauld) - Back to Ref League Table
John Fleming
(Glasgow) - Back to Ref League Table
John Young
(Thornliebank) - Back to Ref League Table
Graeme Alison
(Dumfries) - Back to Ref League Table
Martin Clark
(Edinburgh) - Back to Ref League Table