REFEREE RATINGS FOR 2007-2008
A quick listing of the referees Saints have in their
competitive games this season along with an average rating out of 10 and
description of the various cock-ups they made. Suggestions for suitable
awards to the best/ worst of the season and any additional ratings to
refvote@grange.demon.co.uk.
Last Seasons Inagural Votes are available for perusal
for 1997-98, 1998-99,
1999-2000, 2000-01,
2001-02, 2002-03 ,2003-04,
2004-05, 2005-06
and 2006-07
Current
Ratings ::
Match Details +
Total Ratings
David Somers-
Back to Ref League Table
- 26/04/08 Saints v Livi 39 (7 votes)
- Not bad - kept cards to a minimum and at least spotted the penalties
- 22/03/08 Partick v Saints23 (7
votes) - Poor decisions and soft cards dished out didn't help a
crap game
- 22/09/07 Morton v Saints22 (3 votes)
- Dished the cards when he needed to and a decent game overall.
Scott
MacDonald - Back to Ref League Table
- 23/04/08 Stirling v Saints 14 (3
votes) - Two penalties for them, none for us and some nightmarish
decisions. The new Shuggy Dallas?
- 10/11/07 Saints v Pars 23 (10 votes)
- Utter pish - no control over the game, crap linesman and an inability
to spot a foul from five yards away. Makes Brines look normal.
Dougie McDonald
(Edinburgh)- Back to Ref League Table
- 20/04/08 Saints v TFOD (Scottish Cup Semi) 140
(31 votes) - Not a bad game overall but a soft penalty to them
and God knows how Dailly stayed on the park
- 05/04/08 Hamilton v Saints 25 (8
votes) - Poor game and a controversial 2nd goal for the home side
and some inconsistencies didn't help.
- 18/03/08 St Mirren v Saints (Scottish Cup Replay)58
(8 votes)- Good solid game tonight - no arguments about the
penalties and kept cards to a minimum
- 08/03/08 Saints v St Mirren (Scottish Cup)50
(8 votes)- Decent enough game but a few soft bookings. Stopped
things boiling over though.
Mike Tumilty-
Back to Ref League Table
- 12/04/08 Saints v Morton 51 (9
votes) - Tried to let the game flow but some soft bookings and
poor advantage didn't help.
- 15/12/07 Accies v Saints 12 (6
votes) - Should have red-carded Mensing but little real
controversy. Too much timewasting though.
- 15/09/07 Saints v Partick51 (9
votes) - Decent game with cards kept in his pocket
Mike McCurry
(Wegieland) - Back to Ref League Table
- 29/03/08 Saints v Pars 44 (9 votes)
- Decent enough game given the conditions and cards kept to a minimum
- 28/08/07 Partick v Saints46 (10
votes) - Pish decisions but consistently pish
Eddie SmithBack
to Ref League Table
- 25/03/08 Saints v Clyde 35 (6 votes)
- Two penalties for us and a decent enough game overall.
- 25/11/07 Saints v Pars (Challenge Cup Final)71
(19 votes) - Another penalty for each side but some strange
decisions. Still who cares!!
- 29/09/07 Saints v Hamilton28 (13
votes) - Gave us a penalty but generally very poor. Far too
whistle-happy.
Steve Conroy-
Back to Ref League Table
- 15/03/08 Livi v Saints42 (7 votes)-
Fairly good game with little real controversy. Only one card dished out
as well as the game rarely blew up
- 02/10/07 Morton v Saints (Challenge Cup Semi-Final)
18 (5 votes) - Only two cards
dished out but missed the foul on Jacko and a blatant elbow on the Doc.
Very poor control
Brian Winter
Back to Ref League Table
- 11/03/08 Saints v QoS37 (7 votes)-
Decent enough game and tried to keep his cards in his pockets but
possibly let too many heavy challenges go unpunished early on.
Stuart Dougal
(Burnside) - Back to Ref League Table
- 01/03/08 Dundee v Saints54 (13
votes)- Not a bad game - some soft fouls but no real complaints
- 05/01/08 Saints v Partick 64 (12
votes) - Not too bad a game with no cards but some inconsistent
decisions
- 02/09/07 Pars v Saints36 (9 votes)
- No cards but some strange and infuriating decisions for both sets of
fans - is he really the best?
John
McKendrick - Back to Ref League Table
- 25/08/07 Clyde v Saints 36 (10
votes) - Crap at dishing out cards and a bit whistle happy. At
least he spotted some of the Bully Wee's dives.
- 23/02/08 Morton v Saints 45 (11
votes) - Some soft bookings for Saints and little for the home
side but to be fair tried to play advantage and spotted most of the
incidents
Euan Norris-
Back to Ref League Table
- 16/02/08 Saints v Accies 40 (33
votes) - An absolute stinker with total lack of control of the
play aided and abetted by two abysmal linesmen
- 27/10/07 Saints v Clyde 28 (8 votes)
- Very card-happy and some strange decisions. Lucky nothing
controversial though
William Collum-
Back to Ref League Table
- 01/12/2007 Partick v Saints 27 (9
votes) - Utter pish. Poor decisions all day and an only gets some
points for eventually giving us a penalty and warning Tufty about his
timewasting.
- 12/02/08 Ross Co v Saints (Scottish Cup) 24
(5 votes) - Wasn't there so no comments from me.
Stevie O'Reilly-
Back to Ref League Table
- 09/02/07 QoS v Saints35 (11 votes)
- Absolutely dire with some woeful inconsistencies.
Craig ThomsonBack
to Ref League Table
- 26/01/08 Saints v Stirling 63 (10
votes)- Good solid came with little controversy.
- 22/12/07 Saints v Livi 42 (8 votes)
- Some strange bookings but tried to let the game flow. Bit dodgy on the
handball rule though....
John Underhill
(Edinburgh) - Back to Ref League Table
- 19/01/08 Pars v Saints 42(13 votes)
- Mr inconsistent with soft penalty awards, controversial offsides and
unable to play advantage for Saints.
Stephen Finnie-
Back to Ref League Table
- 15/01/08 Saints v Raith (Scottish Cup) 42
(8 votes) - Some strange decisions but nothing controversial and
tried to let the game flow
Chris Boyle-
Back to Ref League Table
- 02/01/08 Saints v Scumdee 41 (11
votes) - Bit card-happy and some daft decisions but kept control
of the tempers.
- 14/08/07 Raith v Saints (Challenge Cup) 39
(9 votes) - Gave us a penalty but that was about it in a pretty
fussy game.
Iain Brines -
Back to Ref League Table
- 29/12/07 Clyde v Saints 13 (3 votes)
- Pretty poor overall but at least he was the same for both sides.
- 03/11/07 Scumdee v Saints 69 (15
votes) - Inconsistent pish from one of the worst referees of the
season.
- 05/09/07 Ross Co v Saints (Challenge Cup) 17
(3 votes) - Wasn't there so no comment from me.
- 04/08/07 QoS v Saints 66 (13 votes)
- Gave us 2 penalties but seemed to be unwilling to dish out cards or to
punish some of the tugging and climbing that went on. Not his best game
but could have been worse.
Alan Freeland
(Sheepville) - Back to Ref League Table
- 26/12/07 Stirling v Saints 11 (8
votes) - Utter pish. Totally incompetent performance missing
challenges for both sides and unable to let the game flow.
- 18/08/07Saints v Scumdee 58 (13
votes) - Red-carded Hardie and some strange decisions at times
but kept the game flowing. Needs better understanding with his linesmen
Colin Brown-
Back to Ref League Table
- 08/12/07 Saints v Morton 19 (7
votes) - Got a penalty but that was it with a total lack of
control of the game. Pish for both sides
Crawford AllanBack
to Ref League Table
- 20/10/07 Saints v QoS - 59 (11
votes) - A decent all-round performance with no daft decisions
that spring to mind
- 18/09/07 Saints v Brechin (Challenge Cup) 27
(5 votes) - Not bad but gave Mooner silly booking. Little
controversy in the game
Alan Boyd-
Back to Ref League Table
- 06/10/07 Livi v Saints 37 (19 votes)
- Absolute nightmare with the weirdest interpretation of the rules I've
ever seen
Alan Muir-
Back to Ref League Table
- 11/08/07 Saints v Stirling 26 (7
votes) - A decent game for the first 75 minutes or so with few
cards dished out but failed to clamp down on some of the grudge tackles
late on.
Colin Hardie-
Back to Ref League Table
Charlie
Richmond- Back to Ref League Table
Kenny Clark
(Paisley) - Back to Ref League Table
Mike RitchieBack
to Ref League Table
Craig Mackay
- Back to Ref League Table
Martin Sproule-
Back to Ref League Table
Calum Murray-
Back to Ref League Table
Ian
Frickleton- Back to Ref League Table
Ian Fyfe-
Back to Ref League Table
Andrew Hunter
- Back to Ref League Table
Steven Duff-
Back to Ref League Table